Strategies to Find Off Market Multifamily Properties

(Updated June 2025)

When it comes to finding off market multifamily home deals, I like to focus on spotting subtle clues, like rent signs that indicate potential opportunities, while crafting a comprehensive guide tailored to close buyers efficiently, a process that’s highly dependent on strategic planning and relationship-building.

For savvy real estate investors, off market multifamily properties present a unique path to excellent opportunities. Unlike market multifamily properties, which are publicly listed and highly competitive, off market multifamily properties aren’t advertised on public platforms, such as the multiple listing service (MLS).

These off market property deals can often lead to securing properties at a higher price advantage and negotiating directly with property owners for better terms. Finding these off market deals, however, requires a distinct approach. It starts with cultivating relationships and it can also include direct outreach. Your success in the real estate market hinges on proactive strategies and a personalized approach.

Here are my nine favorite, actionable ways to find off market multifamily deals and turn them into profitable real estate investments. These ideas are a great addition to your real estate investment pitch deck, if you regularly pitch other investors.

1. Building Relationships with Real Estate Brokers

One of the most effective ways to access off market multifamily properties is by forming strong relationships with trusted real estate brokers. These professionals are often privy to pocket listings and exclusive listings—properties not advertised publicly. Brokers can connect you to potential sellers and motivated buyers while offering insights into the market multifamily deals unavailable to most.

To maximize this relationship you may consider this.

• Work with brokers specializing in multifamily properties.
• Communicate your investment criteria, such as units, budget, and desired location.
• Be responsive and reliable; brokers prioritize buyers who are serious and ready to act.

Brokers often act as gatekeepers to the real estate business, so cultivating trust can open doors to great deals.

2. Direct Outreach and Networking Strategies

Direct outreach and networking are indispensable in finding off market properties. Attending industry events, such as real estate market conferences or local investor meetups, allows you to connect with fellow investors, property managers, and multifamily owners.

Tips you can follow for maximizing networking.

• Join associations like landlord or property management groups.
• Build partnerships with other investors who may pass along potential deals.
• Create a targeted list of property owners and directly contact them to express your interest in their investment property.

Networking isn’t a one-time event but an ongoing process of relationship-building that positions you closer to off market deals.

3. My Go-To Online Platforms and Resources for Off Market Multifamily Properties

It is my experience that finding how to find off market multifamily properties almost always starts with the right tools. Every once in a while, I’ll use LoopNet, Crexi, or even Zillow, not because they’re secret, but because I think that, if you pay attention, you’ll notice some distressed properties and pocket listings pop up that most folks overlook. I love how these platforms can reveal small multifamily deals you’d never find searching for properties officially listed for sale.

I always recommend joining online forums and social media groups where local real estate investors share leads, market trends, and even those rare properties off market. One of my clients actually found a terrific deal after networking in a Facebook group focused on multifamily real estate in different markets. Sometimes, I’ll even browse the county tax assessor’s website looking for owners behind on taxes. Many multifamily owners who run into financial headaches become prospective sellers before listing publicly.

To me, searching public platforms is only half the game. I think that a strategic approach, digging deeper and building relationships, lets you find off market deals most people miss.

4. Driving for Dollars and Canvassing

The old school still works. Every once in a while, I would get in my car and just start driving neighborhoods I like. In my experience, “driving for dollars” is still one of the most effective ways to spot off market multifamily properties, especially in local markets. I’m looking for vacant, rundown, or poorly maintained buildings. These often belong to owners who are more open to an offer. This was my mindset when I would do it.

• Write down the addresses that catch my eye.
• Look up ownership info on the county tax assessor’s website.
• Reach out, sometimes with a letter, sometimes with a phone call.

I also think that walking the neighborhood, canvassing buildings, and chatting with property management teams can uncover properties off market, especially if you’re hunting for small multifamily or single family homes with multiple units. Sometimes, that direct conversation leads to a purchase and sale agreement you’d never see on the MLS.

5. Why I Rely on Wholesalers and Bird Doggers

It is my experience that working with wholesalers and bird doggers is a real shortcut to finding deals. Wholesalers deal with all the upfront work, finding, negotiating, and even putting properties under contract before passing the deal to investors like us. Bird doggers, on the other hand, scout for leads and sell that info to people ready to act.

I think that having a strong network is key. Many owners never list their multifamily real estate for sale, but wholesalers and bird doggers are in the know. These relationships mean you can find off market deals while focusing on what you do best.

6. Looking at Probate and Foreclosure Auctions

I’ll check out probate sales and foreclosure auctions. In my opinion, these are gold mines for investors looking to find off market multifamily properties at a discount. Probate properties and foreclosures often aren’t marketed the same way as your typical market multifamily listings, so you have less competition.

I love how this can lead to terrific deals. Sometimes, the sale price is better because the seller needs to move quickly. Just be sure you know the process and have your financing lined up.

7. How Direct Mail Marketing and Cold Calling Still Get Results

One thing I’ll always do is send direct mail or pick up the phone for a cold call. I think that a personal letter or a well-placed call still stands out in a world of digital noise.

• Send professional but engaging mail pieces to multifamily owners.
• Include language expressing your interest in property investment and solutions for financial issues.
• Cold call with confidence, focusing on how your offer benefits the owners.

Many multifamily owners appreciate a direct approach, and this often reaches prospective sellers before they even consider listing their properties for sale. I use my customer relationship management system to keep track of follow-ups, responses, and the status of each lead. This way, I make sure no opportunity slips through the cracks.

8. Networking with Local Real Estate Professionals

It is my experience that some of the best good deals in multifamily investing never show up online, they’re shared privately between trusted connections. I love how just keeping in touch with other local real estate investors, property managers, lenders, and even contractors can give you the inside scoop on properties about to go up for sale private, especially when you’re focused on finding multifamily properties. Every once in a while, I’ll get a text from a broker about a property address he heard about through the grapevine, long before it’s ever listed.

My advice? Be specific about what you’re looking for, not just buying single family homes, but exactly the size and location of multifamily real estate you want. Follow up regularly and offer value back. You’ll be amazed how many good deals come from these connections over time.

9. Tenant Referrals and Word of Mouth

One of my clients landed a great property just by having regular conversations with tenants and local business owners in the neighborhoods where he wanted to find multifamily properties. I think that tenants, especially in smaller buildings, often know when an owner is ready to sell or thinking of a private sale. Sometimes, I’ll even leave my card with tenants or ask them if they’ve heard about anyone considering selling. It’s surprising how many good deals pop up this way, long before the property address shows up anywhere public.

I love how this approach works for both buying single family homes and multifamily investing. Don’t be shy about offering a finder’s fee if a referral turns into a real opportunity. A little goodwill and word of mouth can open the door to deals you’d never find otherwise.

Check Back for Updates for Find Off Market Multifamily Deals

Successfully navigating the world of off market multifamily investing requires blending creativity with calculated strategy. Whether utilizing pocket listings, browsing innovative tools, or building connections with fellow investors, staying proactive is the key to unlocking great deals.

Begin applying these nine strategies today and discover how off market multifamily properties can transform your real estate business.

Join Our Real Estate Professional Network

About the Author